Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Advice to Tutors

I am taking an English course this quarter in Lancaster, and the professor of the class is unlike anyone I have met before in my academic career. As a writing tutor, we are encouraged to assist students in various areas of their papers. It seems most of the students probably wouldn't utilize the learning center if not told about it's existence and required by their professor to at least show up here once. In my English course, the professor does not recommend that students see tutors, or have their peers look at current papers because any influence could destroy the writers voice. At the same time, some do not know how to begin to use their voice and that's where tutors come in. We sort of present guidelines, a lens or perspective as a starting point. It does take a lot to be criticized, and it is indeed difficult to come into a writing center under the impression that someone else is going to tear their writing piece apart. I almost feel torn this winter session because my professor has a viewpoint that is an extreme opposite on the spectrum of helping other writers. There has got to be a balance somewhere in there that addresses helping a student without destroying their voice. Not everyone is a writer!

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Peter Elbow would disagree. :-)

It's always good to get other viewpoints, so I'm glad you get to hear from other professors.It's true that many strong writers may not need/want feedback--especially in creative pieces.

Still, in academic essays, I believe writing in a vacuum can be nonproductive . . . Just sayin'

Unknown said...

Very few of us know what are voice is at first or even after years of searching. Asking for tutoring isn’t asking someone to speak for you. Going to the writing center helps clarify issues that might be impeding your writing skills. Getting over the grammar hurdles and formatting styles can help free the mind up to be creative. Instead of constantly reading your work over and over, you can just let the stream of creative writing flow. Blindly searching for simple mistakes can take up a lot of time. Having the help of a tutor to guide you through some of the mechanics of writing is a valuable resource.
Professors may give a list of reasons why they think going to the writing center isn’t a great idea. Maybe there is a hidden lesson to be learned. Personally, I would rather have a guide than jump in blindly. If a writing professor truly thinks there should be no help—hopefully they didn’t assign a text for the course.